Is everyone leaving Substack? What the data shows in 2026

No. About 129,000 new Substack newsletters started between January and September 2026, 22% more than in the same months of 2025. Some well-known writers did leave, and here is why.

By Letterstats research team · Updated · 3 min read

No. The data shows more people starting newsletters on Substack, not fewer. About 129,000 new public newsletters published their first post between January and September 2026, 22% more than the 106,000 in the same months of 2025. Some well-known writers have left, and their reasons are real, but they are a small group compared with the number arriving.

These figures come from Letterstats, which tracks more than 520,000 public Substack newsletters every day. Data as of 16 November 2026, updated monthly.

New newsletters started each month

Newsletters by the month of their first public post, and how many of them still posted in the last 90 days:

MonthStartedStill posting
Jan 202513,4667,147
Apr 202511,5036,150
Jul 202512,4576,984
Oct 202510,7316,885
Jan 202616,34810,839
Apr 202613,0519,420
Jul 202614,75111,876
Sep 202614,15013,178
PeriodNew newsletters
January–September 2025105,704
January–September 2026129,364
Change+22%

October 2026 is left out because our crawler finds new newsletters with a delay of a few weeks.

So why do people say everyone is leaving?

Because some prominent writers have left, loudly. Over the past few years their reasons have usually been one of these:

  • Content moderation. Some writers and readers object to which publications Substack allows and promotes.
  • The 10% fee. For a newsletter making $500,000 a year, Substack's 10% is $50,000. Ghost and beehiiv take 0% of paid subscriptions and charge a monthly plan instead, which costs far less at that size. See beehiiv vs Substack and Ghost vs Substack.
  • Owning the brand. Substack's app, Notes and recommendations make it feel like a social network, and some writers want their newsletter to feel like their own site.
  • Missing features. Advanced segmentation, automations and design control are limited compared with email marketing tools.

Do writers who leave take their readers?

Yes. Substack lets writers export their subscriber list, and paid subscribers can move with them through Stripe. That is why leaving is possible for large newsletters, and also why Substack works hard on features that are hard to take with you: recommendations, Notes and the app.

Who stays, and why

Most writers stay because of what is hard to get elsewhere:

  • Recommendations. Other Substack writers recommend you to their new subscribers. This is the biggest growth channel for small newsletters in our data. See how long it takes to get 1,000 subscribers.
  • No cost until you earn. Substack is free for free newsletters and only takes a share of paid revenue.
  • The reader network. Readers who already pay for one Substack can subscribe to another in one click.

Is Substack still worth it in 2026?

On fees alone, flat-price platforms become cheaper earlier than most writers think. Ghost's Publisher plan costs $29 a month at 1,000 members billed yearly, about $348 a year, so Substack's 10% costs more once paid revenue passes about $3,500 a year. beehiiv's Lite plan is $119 a month at 10,000 subscribers billed yearly, so the crossover there is about $14,300 a year (plan prices checked on 14 November 2026).

What a flat fee doesn't buy is Substack's network. Substack says its network "drives more than 50% of all subscriptions on the platform", through recommendations, the app and Notes. For a growing newsletter, that reach is usually worth more than the fee. Use the Substack fees calculator to see what Substack and Stripe take at your price and size.

Questions people ask

Why is everyone leaving Substack?

They aren't, in aggregate: about 129,000 new public Substack newsletters started between January and September 2026, 22% more than a year earlier (Letterstats data). Some well-known writers have left over content moderation, the 10% fee at high revenue, or wanting more control of their brand.

What is replacing Substack?

For writers who leave, the usual alternatives are beehiiv, Ghost and Kit (formerly ConvertKit), plus Patreon for creators who also sell video or audio. Substack takes 10% of paid revenue; Ghost and beehiiv take 0% and charge a monthly plan; Kit charges 3.5% + 30 cents per sale including card fees; Patreon takes 10% for creators who launched after August 4, 2025.

Is Substack still growing?

Yes. More newsletters published their first post on Substack in each month from January to September 2026 than in the same month of 2025, according to Letterstats' tracking of more than 520,000 public newsletters.

Is Substack dying?

No. New newsletter starts were up 22% year over year in January–September 2026, and about 1,180 active newsletters show 1,000 or more paying subscribers (Letterstats, November 2026).