| 1 | Poetry UnboundPoetry Unbound · Literature | 141K | 169K | | $8/mo | $84K–$475K |
| 2 | We are the weirdos, mister.Leigh Bardugo · Literature | 123K | 129K | | $5/mo | $2.7K–$4.5K |
| 3 | Catherine ShannonCatherine Shannon · Literature | 61K | 82K | | $8/mo | $28K–$77K |
| 4 | The New York Review of BooksThe New York Review of Books · Literature | 53K | 87K | | Free | — |
| 5 | Silent Book ClubSilent Book Club · Literature | 50K | 56K | | $5/mo | $20K–$67K |
| 6 | Human StuffLisa Olivera · Literature | 41K | 71K | | $5/mo | $11K–$46K |
| 7 | Before and After the Book DealCourtney Maum · Literature | 39K | 71K | | $6.5/mo | $58K–$93K |
| 8 | Memoir LandSari Botton · Literature | 36K | 223K | | $5/mo | $9.9K–$47K |
| 9 | Susan WiggsSusan Wiggs · Literature | 33K | 34K | | Free | — |
| 10 | Boletim TatuíBoletim Tatuí · Literature | 31K | 33K | | Free | — |
| 11 | Live Your StoryKristy Woodson Harvey · Literature | 31K | 32K | | Free | — |
| 12 | Club Bubbly by Beach Reads & BubblyKatie of Beach Reads & Bubbly · Literature | 29K | 31K | | $5/mo | $46K–$73K |
| 13 | The Elif LifeElif Batuman · Literature | 27K | 42K | | $6/mo | $57K–$91K |
| 14 | NNarratively AcademyNarratively Academy · Literature | 26K | 32K | | $15/mo | $17K–$106K |
| 15 | Club ReticentValerie · Literature | 25K | 36K | | $7/mo | $8.5K–$53K |
| 16 | Necessary Salt by Joy SullivanJoy Sullivan · Literature | 24K | 34K | | $5/mo | $6.8K–$43K |
| 17 | BelletristBelletrist · Literature | 24K | 25K | | $5/mo | $280–$460 |
| 18 | Writing in the Dark with Jeannine OuelletteJeannine Ouellette · Literature | 21K | 47K | | $7/mo | $67K–$108K |
| 19 | PrufrockMicah Mattix · Literature | 20K | 25K | | $5/mo | $6.0K–$38K |
| 20 | Friends & Fiction Endless StoriesFriends & Fiction · Literature | 20K | 26K | | $5/mo | $5.4K–$34K |
| 21 | SenLinYu’s SubstackSenLinYu · Literature | 18K | 20K | | Free | — |
| 22 | Book EnthusiastBecca Freeman · Literature | 17K | 28K | | $5/mo | $48K–$79K |
| 23 | August's NewsletterAugust Lamm · Literature | 15K | 19K | | $5/mo | $3.9K–$22K |
| 24 | Woman of LettersNaomi Kanakia · Literature | 15K | 25K | | $5/mo | $4.0K–$22K |
| 25 | MidstackJessica Smock · Literature | 11K | 20K | | $10/mo | $5.8K–$23K |
| 26 | The BleedersCourtney Kocak · Literature | 10K | 14K | | $9/mo | $3.6K–$6.1K |
| 27 | Lit Club NYCLit Club NYC · Literature | 9,800 | 14K | | $8/mo | $7.9K–$52K |
| 28 | BBuffy's Buffy's · Literature | 9,400 | 15K | | Free | $230–$760 |
| 29 | Heavy MetaTarra · Literature | 9,100 | 12K | | $8/mo | $7.7K–$50K |
| 30 | Andrea Bartz: Get It WriteAndrea Bartz · Literature | 8,300 | 15K | | $6/mo | $5.6K–$33K |
| 31 | Not So Secret AgentSally Ekus · Literature | 7,800 | 18K | | $8/mo | $7.7K–$43K |
| 32 | The Everygirl Book ClubThe Everygirl Book Club · Literature | 7,700 | 7,899 | | $5/mo | $3.7K–$4.4K |
| 33 | Open Book Club NYCElizabeth · Literature | 7,500 | 9,792 | | $5/mo | $4.7K–$25K |
| 34 | Devon HallidayDevon Halliday · Literature | 6,900 | 8,474 | | Free | — |
| 35 | Bridge BooksGriffin Shea · Literature | 6,800 | 6,977 | | $5/mo | $200–$330 |
| 36 | Mark NepoMark Nepo · Literature | 6,800 | 13K | | $5/mo | $4.8K–$23K |
| 37 | Going Solo at the End of the WorldMarya Hornbacher · Literature | 6,000 | 8,485 | | $5/mo | $5.0K–$21K |
| 38 | The Point’s SubstackThe Point · Literature | 5,900 | 9,201 | | Free | — |
| 39 | Jenna’s SubstackJenna Levine · Literature | 5,400 | 5,550 | | Free | — |
| 40 | The Substack BookstoreFleur Hull · Literature | 5,000 | 8,612 | | $47/mo | $26K–$93K |
| 41 | Kristina Forest's NewsletterKristina Forest · Literature | 4,700 | 5,103 | | Free | — |
| 42 | VERVE POETRYVERVE Poetry · Literature | 4,500 | 6,199 | | £3.5/mo | $2.2K–$4.4K |
| 43 | moonseedHala Alyan · Literature | 4,400 | 7,702 | | $5/mo | $4.8K–$15K |
| 44 | The Seeker with Brad WetzlerPodcast · Brad Wetzler · Literature | 4,200 | 5,828 | | $8/mo | $3.4K–$7.3K |
| 45 | Author InsiderPanio Gianopoulos · Literature | 4,000 | 98K | | $30/mo | $12K–$28K |
| 46 | Blue HourStacey · Literature | 4,000 | 5,399 | | Free | — |
| 47 | casualreadersclubcasualreadersclub · Literature | 3,900 | 4,015 | | £8/mo | $550–$910 |
| 48 | SubtractionCharlotte Wood · Literature | 3,700 | 8,286 | | Free | — |
| 49 | SWWIM Every DaySWWIM Every Day · Literature | 3,600 | 7,132 | | $8/mo | $3.0K–$7.7K |
| 50 | The Latest From LittsburghLittsburgh · Literature | 3,500 | 3,831 | | Free | — |